Toney Mustachia, born July 29th, 1907 in Pine Bluff, AR, was a professional baseball umpire from 1946-1951.1 Biography Mustachia died on January 8th, 1966 in Houston, TX and was buried in St. Joseph's Cemetery in Pine Bluff, AR.2 1 Mustachia's TSN umpire card. 2 Mustachia's Texas death certificate.